Can You Rate 10 Random Magic Cards, According to Gatherer?

You may also like...

3 Responses

  1. Alex C says:

    I came… vaguely close. I had Killer Bees top and Devoted Druid second. Ana Battlemage spot on at 3; the Ooze and the Giant the other way around at 4 and 5. I had Righteous Cause spot on at 6, but then I was much worse on the bottom few. I had the Plowbeast at 7 because it’s solid in Naya Limited, Thoughtlace at 8 because… I thought the Laces were so bad they’d have their fans, maybe? Not quite sure what I was thinking there. Cohort at 9 and Knight Errant at 10 because vanilla. I’m still stunned that a vanilla 2/2 without the heredity of Grizzly Bears can get 2.8 stars.

    Fun. Do indeed do it again 🙂

  2. jmgariepy says:

    I plan to. This was one of those odd articles where most people blew by it, but the people who ‘got it’ really like it. It isn’t hard to reproduce (just, you know, time), and I’m guessing the more I do, the more people will start to catch on.

    I do find it funny how hard it is to call those bottom cards. It’s not something we really practice as Magic players. The difference between the Plowbeast and the Knight is the biggest jump on the list. But, yeah, I expect many to most people would get that wrong.

  1. July 13, 2013

    […] Learn more at JM’s blog… […]

Leave a Reply